Why is this happening? Hitori (Full Version)

 Message

 Vitol -> Why is this happening? Hitori (4/18/2018 7:49:17 PM) If you see any solved Hitori, the black squares are always connected diagonally with another black square, and this with another and so on until they reach one of the sides of the puzzle. Nothing like "island black squares", but the rules don't say anything about this. Why is this happening? What is the math behind this?

 flarbear -> RE: Why is this happening? Hitori (8/23/2018 1:20:25 AM) This has gone a long time without an answer. I'm not a puzzle creator, but I can speculate on why puzzles are constructed this way. I believe that it has to do with the rule that a mark cannot divide the grid. The long chains create opportunities where the solver has to decide which of two cells in one row or column need to be marked and they find that one of them must be left open because filling it in would connect a pair of those long chains and divide the puzzle. If all of the cells were disconnected throughout the puzzle, then that rule wouldn't come into play in solving it. And given that this rule is one of the more abstract rules that requires a more global awareness of the entire grid in order to apply, it is thus a popular one to use to make the puzzles harder to solve.

 Ahlyis -> RE: Why is this happening? Hitori (8/24/2018 7:05:53 PM) Flarbear's response doesn't seem correct to me. There cannot be any "loops" in the puzzle or the puzzle becomes unsolvable. Picture a puzzle that you are solving and you've reached a point where you only have 2 squares left to decide whether they are black or not. These two squares, if left clear would form the loop around a group of black squares, as Vitol is asking about. In that case, you could never solve the puzzle because either one of those squares "could" be black and the other clear and the puzzle would still be "solved correctly". Any disconnected group of black squares, not connected to any edge of the puzzle, would necessarily allow multiple solutions to the puzzle.

 Vitol -> RE: Why is this happening? Hitori (8/27/2018 10:03:26 PM) what about the forced isolated '7' black square on the right bottom? This case wouldn't drive us to a multiple solution puzzle and i never saw something like this (the example is wrong just for show u the case) [image]https://s33.postimg.cc/g5fumez3z/qdqqdq.png[/image]

 Ahlyis -> RE: Why is this happening? Hitori (8/31/2018 8:01:36 PM) That's an interesting example. It's hard to say whether it is valid or not since the rest of the puzzle is unsolvable. But as a concept, I cannot immediately see any reason why that shouldn't work. Okay, I withdraw my claim that an unsecured group would necessarily mandate multiple solutions. I'm not yet convinced there isn't anything to it since we don't have a legitimate example so far, but I'm no longer certain either way. ;)

 sslug -> RE: Why is this happening? Hitori (2/16/2019 8:05:25 AM) Here is a puzzle with a group of "floating" black squares (https://www.chiark.greenend.org.uk/~sgtatham/puzzles/js/singles.html#12x12dk#772279161597768): [image]local://39778/6929381BA9C449668E25E68B3BEA5B91.jpg[/image]

 mig23 -> RE: Why is this happening? Hitori (2/18/2019 3:19:59 PM) I'm not sure this last puzzle actually works. When I was solving it there was a "flash" when I clicked on a centrally located nine (row 6, column 7). I'm thinking that means it is an error, but I might be wrong. If I continue and "solve" the puzzle it doesn't show that it is completed.

 Ahlyis -> RE: Why is this happening? Hitori (2/18/2019 7:13:52 PM) quote:ORIGINAL: mig23 I'm not sure this last puzzle actually works. When I was solving it there was a "flash" when I clicked on a centrally located nine (row 6, column 7). I'm thinking that means it is an error, but I might be wrong. If I continue and "solve" the puzzle it doesn't show that it is completed. That flash was (most likely) the game telling you that you solved it. If the site is checking only for the correct squares marked black, and considers the circled squares irrelevant to the solution, then clicking on the 9 as the last black square solved the puzzle and gave you the flash. I haven't played much with Singles there (their name for Hitori), but I know other puzzles on that site use the flash to indicate a correctly solved puzzle. EDIT: Just tried it. I got the flash when I clicked on the last black square, a 5 for me, while I still had 2 other squares that would be circles but were not yet marked. The rules state "Black out some of the squares, in such a way that...". The puzzle is solved when the last black square is marked correctly. EDIT #2: If you want a 5x5 puzzle that has an island black, try this one: https://www.chiark.greenend.org.uk/~sgtatham/puzzles/js/singles.html#5x5:2234532512144225412335532

 Ahlyis -> RE: Why is this happening? Hitori (2/18/2019 7:32:32 PM) As for the original question, perhaps the algorithm that Conceptis uses to generate Hitori puzzles doesn't allow for islands, even though they are legal and possible (as was just proven by sslug).

 wardrose -> RE: Why is this happening? Hitori (7/1/2022 7:42:48 AM) I didn't score any goals for any Hitori match, I need a wise play guide. If there are any math related solutions it would be interesting for me to win. cookie clicker

 htyker -> RE: Why is this happening? Hitori (7/5/2022 2:22:25 AM) That seems to me that there has been a mistake, although I could be mistaken. Even after I "solve" the puzzle, it doesn't appear to be finished. basket random

 ErikaTyler -> RE: Why is this happening? Hitori (7/5/2022 10:07:12 AM) I played very hard, but then I lost. Why so? phoodle

 dave -> RE: Why is this happening? Hitori (7/7/2022 9:27:53 PM) This is because you are missing one of the rules. Please post your solution here and some of our puzzle fans will explain what you did wrong. Thanks, Dave

 Page: [1]